Which classic rpgs hold up the best?

Chrono Trigger is widely praised for its timeless quality, and Baldur's Gate 2 does everything right despite some age related clunkiness.

What makes Planescape Torment stand out?

Users frequently highlight its exceptional writing and philosophical narrative, describing it as being as good as a proper novel.

Why is Baldur's Gate 3 considered a top rpg?

It is recognized for high production value, vast content, and significant player choice, leading many to call it a generational title.

Best Rpgs of All Time Top Picks

Q: How does Cyberpunk 2077 fit into the rpg conversation?

With the Phantom Liberty expansion, users note its character decisions, build variety, and multiple endings make it a strong contender for best all around game.

There is no single consensus on the best rpg of all time, but several titles consistently receive heavy praise from users.

Classic games like Chrono Trigger, Baldur's Gate 2, and Planescape Torment are celebrated for their writing, story, and timeless design, despite some clunkiness from age.

Modern releases like Baldur's Gate 3 and Cyberpunk 2077 stand out for their high production values, player choice, and expansive content.

Top picks

Chrono Trigger timeless quality that holds up for adult players
Baldur's Gate 2 does everything right despite clunky age
Planescape Torment philosophical writing as good as a novel
Baldur's Gate 3 high production value and vast player choice
Cyberpunk 2077 great builds, character decisions, and endings
The Witcher 3 immersive narrative and choose your own adventure feel
Dragon Age Origins immaculate lore, companions, and world building
Morrowind complex gameplay and deep lore in an original setting
Fallout New Vegas deep narratives and strong roleplaying elements

While there's no single consensus for the best RPG of all time, many Users frequently mention Chrono Trigger, Baldur's Gate 2, Planescape: Torment, and Dragon Age: Origins as top contenders, often alongside newer titles like Baldur's Gate 3 and Cyberpunk 2077.

Critically Acclaimed RPGs

Chrono Trigger is often praised for its timeless quality. Many Users who played it as adults or replay it regularly still find it holds up exceptionally well. "I never played Chrono Trigger until I was an adult so I feel I can confidently say Chrono Trigger".

Baldur's Gate 2 is considered by some Users to have done everything right, with its only drawback being its age-related clunkiness. "BG2 just does everything right, with its only real weakness being its clunkiness due to its age".

Planescape: Torment is frequently highlighted for its exceptional writing and profound narrative. Users describe it as being as good as a novel and philosophical. "The one to beat is Planescape: Torment. It’s as good as a proper novel."

Modern Favorites

Baldur's Gate 3 is recognized for its high production value, vast content, and significant player choice. Many consider it a generational title in the RPG genre. "Baldurs Gate 3: The production value alone is crazy for an isometric rpg."

Cyberpunk 2077, especially with its Phantom Liberty expansion, is noted for its character decisions, build variety, and multiple endings, making it a strong contender for best all-around game for many. "Cyberpunk 2077 + PL isnt a pure RPG but it's maybe the best all around game of all time in my opinion and there's plenty of character decisions, builds and 8-9 endings".

The Witcher 3 is celebrated for its immersive narrative and detailed game world, providing a choose-your-own-adventure feel. "Witcher 3 is up there for me due to sheer fidelity of the narrative and the game world, it literally feels like walking into a story book, choose-your-own-adventure style."

Other Highly Recommended Titles

Dragon Age: Origins is consistently praised for its story, companions, lore, and world-building, with many considering it an immaculate gem. "The story, the music, the setting, the companions, the lore, the world-building, the RPG, the fantasy, everything about that gem is immaculate."

Morrowind stands out for its unique setting, deep lore, and complex gameplay, although its age can be a factor for some. "To me, it's Morrowind because it has an awesome story, really good side quests and factions, a very original setting and deep lore and the gameplay is complex and full-featured."

Fallout: New Vegas is valued for its deep narratives, strong roleplaying elements, interesting universe, and memorable companions. "Pillars Of Eternity, Dragon Age: Origins, Fallout: New Vegas, Mass Effect, Vampire Masquerade Bloodlines. They are similar in their deep narratives and strong roleplaying elements."

Do you prefer classic or modern RPG experiences?