Why do some players prefer classic RPGs?

They enjoy the difficulty and lack of handholding, finding surviving tough dungeons satisfying. These games also prioritize player creativity and decision making over strict rules.

What makes modern RPGs appealing?

Players appreciate streamlined experiences that respect their time with clear progression. Modern entries also offer extensive voice acting, mature themes, and deeper companion relationship mechanics.

Do RPG preferences change over time?

Yes. As players age, many shift away from complex rules and power fantasies toward lightweight systems and building narrative arcs for low powered characters.

Can you still find classic RPG experiences today?

Yes. While mainstream modern games focus on accessibility, indie developers still create titles that offer lengthy, punishing dungeon crawls and strict resource management.

Classic vs Modern RPGs: Which Style Wins

Users are split between classic and modern RPGs, often finding their preferences shifting as they get older and priorities change.

Classic games earn love for their tough challenges, imaginative freedom, and unique mechanics like detailed economies or character aging.

Modern RPGs attract players with quality of life improvements, deeper companion bonds, and greater accessibility for newcomers.

Classic vs Modern RPGs: Which Style Wins — infographic

Users are divided on preferences between classic and modern RPGs, with many appreciating different aspects of both eras and some finding that their tastes have evolved over time.

Appeal of Classic RPGs

Challenging gameplay. Classic RPGs often feature difficult dungeons, resource management, and less hand-holding, which some Users find more satisfying. "Dungeons were a struggle. And that's what made them so satisfying to get through."

Freedom and player agency. Older RPGs, particularly those in the Old School Revival (OSR) movement, are celebrated for prioritizing player creativity and decision-making over linear narratives. "I feel like OSR games rely more on imagination and inventive play, and 'rulings, not rules' means there were an awful lot less rules lawyers back then."

Unique mechanics and charm. Some classic titles offer distinctive gameplay elements, such as character aging, intricate social systems, or detailed economies, that are less common in modern games. "The housing and having a legitimate economy with you being able to buy houses and rent them, shops (or whorehouses) is pretty cool and not seen in a lot of modern RPGs imo."

Appeal of Modern RPGs

Quality of life improvements. Many Users appreciate modern RPGs for their streamlined experiences, clearer progression, and reduced tediousness compared to older titles. "As an adult now I hate having my time wasted, I consider random battles with little progress, going in circles and stuff like that as time wasted, I love long games, but I need progression."

Immersive storytelling and production values. Contemporary RPGs often feature extensive voice acting, deeper companion relationships, and mature themes that enhance the narrative experience. "Honestly, I know not everyone likes this, but: romance, or at least a mechanic to deepen your bond with your companions."

Accessibility and diverse options. Modern RPGs, including popular titles like Baldur's Gate 3 and Persona 5, are often more welcoming to new players and offer a wide variety of aesthetics and gameplay styles. "These I think all offer perfect jumping-on points to their respective series."

Evolving Tastes and Nuances

Shift in player priorities. As players age, their preferences often shift from power fantasies and complex rules to streamlined experiences and meaningful role-playing. "Today it's all about building narrative arcs for low-powered characters with lightweight systems."

Defining "traditional" is complex. The term "traditional RPG" itself can be ambiguous, with Users offering various interpretations ranging from GM authority to specific game mechanics. "It's better to just ask someone what they mean, because there's a better than average chance that any two people aren't going to mean the same thing."

Indie scene fills niches. While mainstream modern RPGs may not cater to all traditional tastes, the indie game scene often produces titles that offer classic dungeon crawling and resource management experiences. "If you're into lengthy dungeon crawls, you can just play Labyrinth of Galleria or Undernauts or UnderRail or some new Wizardry game and get bullied just like in the good old days."

Are you interested in exploring specific examples of classic or modern RPGs?

Best for: Classic RPGs suit players who love tough challenges and ruling with imagination, while modern RPGs fit those who want accessible narrative and companion depth.