The top EA Sports games mentioned for 2023 include Madden 23, EA FC 24, and NHL, but users widely consider them disappointing due to bugs, minimal improvements, and heavy microtransactions.
Users report that yearly releases feel stale, with gameplay getting worse in some cases. EA FC 24 was called a massive step backwards, and F1 games shipped with serious controller issues. Many say EA prioritizes loot boxes and card packs over actual gameplay development.
Instead of buying new EA Sports titles, many users suggest playing older versions of games like Madden on PS2, or switching to non-EA sports games such as MLB The Show, NBA 2K, and Football Manager for a better experience.
User mentions
Madden 23Some found it improved but many call it broken
EA FC 24Users felt gameplay was a step backwards with unfixed issues
NHLCalled lazy but considered better than Madden by some
MLB The ShowRecommended as the most in-depth non-EA alternative
NBA 2KSuggested as a better sports game outside EA
WWE 2KMentioned alongside NBA 2K as a solid alternative
Football ManagerRecommended by users seeking a non-EA sports title
General Sentiment Towards EA Sports 2023 Games
Lack of improvement: Users feel that EA Sports games, particularly FIFA (now EA FC) and Madden, show minimal improvements year over year. "FIFA peaked in like 2018. Different year, same shit every year since."
Monetization focus: The primary criticism revolves around the heavy emphasis on microtransactions and card packs over actual gameplay development. "It’s frustrating how all major sports games are now more interested in loot boxes, card packs, and gambling."
Bugs and broken features: Many Users report encountering significant bugs and issues in newer EA Sports titles. "The F1 game literally broke my triggers in literally the first thing I tried in the game."
Specific Game Mentions
Madden 23: While some found it enjoyable or improved compared to previous years, many still consider it a "broken game." "Everything I've tried to do within the game has worked. Franchise, superstar, etc. has just simply worked for me."
EA FC 24 (formerly FIFA): Users noted issues with gameplay and server responsiveness. "With FC it felt like a massive step backwards from the 2024 game. The gameplay felt worse and nothing felt fixed."
NHL (various years): Some Users believe that NHL games have become lazy, though others suggest they function better than Madden. "NHL is one of the best EA Sports games)) it just says a lot about current level of EA laziness"
Alternatives to EA Sports
Non-EA Titles: Many Users suggest looking outside of EA for a better sports gaming experience, mentioning games like MLB The Show, NBA 2K, and Football Manager. "I would say mlb the show is the most in depth followed by nba/ wwe 2k. The ea sports games are pretty basic, however I would say over the last 2 years madden has improved a lot."
Older Games: Some prefer playing older versions of sports games, even from a decade or more ago, due to better gameplay and less monetization. "I still break out my PS2 when I want to play Madden. It's been all downhill from there."
Are you looking for a specific sports genre or a particular feature like career mode in a sports game?
Bottom line
Users generally express disappointment with EA Sports' 2023 offerings, citing a lack of innovation and focus on microtransactions. Many suggest avoiding recent EA Sports titles, with some even recommending older games or titles from other developers for a better experience.
FAQ
Are EA Sports games in 2023 worth buying?
Most users say no. They cite minimal year-over-year improvements, heavy microtransactions, and significant bugs as reasons to avoid recent EA Sports titles.
Is Madden 23 any good?
Opinions are mixed. Some users found franchise and superstar modes worked fine and felt it improved over previous years, but many others still consider it a broken game.
Is EA FC 24 better than FIFA?
Users generally felt EA FC 24 was a step backwards, with worse gameplay and unresolved issues compared to previous FIFA titles. Server responsiveness was also noted as a problem.
What are good alternatives to EA Sports games?
Users recommend MLB The Show for depth, along with NBA 2K, WWE 2K, and Football Manager as better sports gaming options outside of EA.
Do older EA Sports games play better than new ones?
Many users prefer older titles, some over a decade old, because they offer better gameplay and far less monetization than current releases.
Are NHL games from EA any good?
Some users call NHL games lazy but still consider them among the better EA Sports titles currently available, which they say reflects poorly on EA overall.
Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.